Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Par For Course, I Suppose

Tsk, Tsk.  I have not been keeping up with posting (not that I've been reading a lot, it's just been keeping me from reading a lot :)) But my reluctance to finish the next book before reviewing the previous one has lead me into contempt of library, because I have a book that's almost a month overdue (oy vey).  So I finished that book and it's time to review the previous one once and for all... Unfortunately, the previous title is a Jill Mansell, meaning I wouldn't have a whole lot to say about it if I had finished it yesterday.  But let's give it a whirl.

So Jill Mansell... you know, these books vary, some are more fun than others.  I never like the ones where the whole tension of the book is the girl thinks the guy is a player, so they don't get together even though they like each other - I mean, you know there's no romance when there's no suspense.  So this (Nadia Knows Best) wasn't one of those but it wasn't any better - girl likes two guys, they both like her, which one does she chooose? Never mind that it takes her a whole book to make the no-brainer choice - where's the romance?! I can't say it wasn't chic lit, that would just be ridiculous - but those chic lit moments were few and far between.  Instead, there was a lot more... well a lot more actual plot going on with Nadia's family and Jay's issues taking up plenty of time.

I mean I suppose it wasn't bad overall - maybe I'm just used to her writing, but I felt like it wasn't as egregious as usual.  And maybe the book didn't even drag on as much as I sometimes feel it does, since there was always something going on.  I mean it's hard for me to even remember my feelings on this one, never mind going back father.  But overall, though it was nothing to write home about, nothing to disuade me from Jill Mansell forever.  But I do hope she goes back to some other chic lit meme for her next one.

Verdict: 2.75/5

3 comments:

  1. Hi Rochel, so sorry my book didn't interest you! I have no idea what a chic lit meme is, but if you suggest one for my next book I would genuinely be very happy to consider it!
    Best
    Jill Mansell

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Ms. Mansell,
      Wow, I'm kind of shocked you read this, in general I'm the only person who ever reads this blog. But in any case, I really do enjoy your books, and I read every new one that comes out, it's just that I like some plots better than others. I liked Miranda's Big Mistake and Perfect Timing a lot for instance. In general, I prefer stories where the couple doesn't get together until the end, or even acknowledge that they like each other until the end, because that's more suspenseful. But that's just my opnion, and I'm sure there are a lot of people who enjoy your other types of plot just as much. In any case, you're the author and I'm sure you know much better than I do what works!

      Delete
  2. No problem, we all have our favourite storylines! I like to hear other people's preferences! Thanks for the review.
    Best
    Jill Mansell

    ReplyDelete